Insight in the power of people: the reversed triangle
A new way to look at power
This guide is also available in PDF format (in Dutch).
From: The politics of nonviolent action, Gene Sharp"In their alone, rulers cannot collect taxes, enforce repressive laws and regulations, keep trains running on time, prepare national budgets, control traffic, manage ports, mint money, repair roads, supply food markets, produce steel, build rockets, train police and soldiers, issue postage stamps, or even milk a cow.People provide these services to the ruler through a variety of organizations and institutions. If people were to stop providing these skills, the ruler could not rule." | Traditional powerTraditional power is often depicted as a pyramid, where power flows from the top down. A janitor takes orders from a location manager, who in turn takes orders from a regional manager, and so on, all the way up to a CEO or head of state at the top of the pyramid. In this view of power, social change happens when we either replace the people at the top (for example, through a regime change or by voting) or when we manage to convince those at the top to change their ways (for example, by educating them through mass public outrage). However, this is not a grassroots way of looking at power: the power remains in the hands of entities like oil companies, and the rest of us can only beg them to do the right thing. We need a new way to view power.A grassroots approach sees power as something that flows upwards: this is what we call the inverted triangle. |
Unjust powerIn this way of viewing power, the manager of an oil company or a head of state is inherently unstable. Like an inverted triangle, unjust power and authority are unstable and can easily collapse. To prevent this, they rely on support points that keep them upright – we call them pillars of support. For example, oil executives are not only reliant on their managers but also on other pillars of support, such as the company’s shareholders, the secretaries who manage their agendas, the technicians who keep their mobile phones and emails operational, the janitors who clean their offices, their limousine drivers, truck drivers, and ship captains who transport their oil, journalists who do not expose their human rights violations, engineers and contractors who build the roads on which oil company trucks travel, customers who buy their products, and so on. Through all these actions, individuals (unwittingly) legitimize the oil companies and support them, allowing them to continue their destructive practices. A campaign from the 1970s illustrates this. The U.S. government sent weapons to the Pakistani dictator Yahya Khan, which were used to massacre the population of East Pakistan (now Bangladesh). It is estimated that three million East Pakistanis were killed in this genocide. A group of Quakers in the United States wanted to make a difference. When they discovered that some of the weapons shipments were being loaded from ports in their own city, they chose a dramatic action to stop the flow of weapons – a sea blockade! For a month, they publicly practiced 'maritime maneuvers' in canoes and kayaks in full view of TV cameras. Some days had special themes, and religious leaders, children, and the elderly worked together in anticipation of the arrival of the massive cargo ships heading to Pakistan. (Read more about the theory and tactics of kayak activism). When the first cargo ship arrived, the group jumped into their canoes and rowboats. The Coast Guard immediately pulled them out, while multiple photographers scrambled to get the best shot. In the following weeks, they played a cat-and-mouse game, with the cargo ships trying to avoid the public spotlight by changing their arrival times or rerouting to other nearby ports. But an important group of people was watching the story unfold on TV: the dockworkers who loaded the ships. The Quakers decided to go to the bars and meet them. The dockworkers were moved by the sincerity of the Quakers and the sense that this was a historic moment. The local longshoremen's union agreed to refuse to load weapons bound for Pakistan. It was the beginning of the end for this weapons shipment. The local dockworkers persuaded the national union to stop loading military shipments to Pakistan. With the loss of this crucial pillar of support, the government could no longer use any port on the East Coast to send weapons. This classic example of civil disobedience made it too costly to send the weapons. Soon after, the federal government announced that it would no longer support the dictator (it will come as no surprise that they did not mention the role of the activists). Without firing a shot or lobbying even once, this small group of activists changed the course of the American empire. That is power. | ![]() People PowerThis is a different conception of 'people power,' where people only collaborate to try to push those in power to change. Instead, the concept of the inverted triangle uses the specific strategy of transforming allies to destabilize power. By analyzing our targets in this way, we may discover new support pillars that we can 'remove' from the system—and we can also better analyze which sources of power we have relationships with and access to in order to enforce change. Read more here about mapping the power of your target. Support PillarsUse this to analyze the power of your campaign target: 1. Start by placing your target in the center. 2. Brainstorm different support pillars. Who supports this target? Even if they don't agree with the target (or don’t care about their position), who are the people who carry out the orders or otherwise hold up a support pillar? Be specific with the names of unions, media conglomerates, secretaries, etc. 3. Optionally, you can take a few and create separate inverted triangles for them with their own support pillars. |
Finally
This text is a translation and adaption of Understanding People Power: the Upside-Down Triangle, a tool developer by 350.org.
Interested in attending a training? Contact us here.
This guide is part of the ‘Toolbox for Movements’. This toolbox contains more short digital guides, offering fundamental knowledge about strategy, movement building, campaigning, and organizing.
We also love to learn. So, if you have any ideas for improving or adding to this guide based on your experiences, let us know!